Sunday, 22 March 2009

Beij 3: Perfume girl kicks up a stink

Perfume Girl (香水女生) will return to school next week, reported The Beijing News on Friday. This is the mundane conclusion of a story that involves Wang Tingting (王亭亭), a fourth-year German language student at Beijing Foreign Language Studies University (BFSU), and her criticism of China’s compulsory foreign language education.

"Buff Tingting"

On March 16th, Wang wrote that because of comments on her blog, which included criticism of China’s Ministry of Education (MOE), she had been forced by the university to quit her studies. While some have backed her criticism of the MOE and BFSU, many netizens have accused the girl of being interested purely in self-promotion - they smelled a rat, rather than perfume, and questioned why she would post so many photographs of herself on a blog entry about being kicked out of school.

The Peking Order, which takes an interest in both Chinese education and girls that look good in pink velour tracksuits, translated some of her blog to see if there is anything to her claims:

Zhao Benshan for Education Minister

In her first critical blog entry, Wang likened China’s Minister of Education to an “executioner with a stranglehold on human talent.” “Exam-based education, compulsory foreign language classes from elementary school, an inflexible college entrance exam system, and universities that do not allow transfer between departments,” she wrote, “are suppressing and destroying human talent.”

Wang went on to recommend Zhao Benshan (赵本山), a well-known Dongbei comedian, for the position of Education Minister. Unlike Zhao, who successfully popularised Dongbei dialect within 10 years, “the Ministry of Education is unable even to fully popularise Mandarin."

When Chinese people think of foreign languages, claimed Perfume Girl, the first thing people think of is not pleasure or fascination, it is “destroyed childhoods and the extreme study pressures of youth.”

Foreign languages depriving Chinese of the right to education

The next blog entry went on to complain that “foreign language study is depriving Chinese people of their right to education.” “Regardless of your interests or which direction you want to head in, whether it is history, Chinese, Chinese medicine, archaeology, foreign languages are a hellish gate that the you must pass through.” However talented someone might be at his or her own subject, she wrote, the talent will be choked out by an inadequate grasp of foreign languages.

Foreign languages holding Chinese people to ransom

In her final diatribe before claiming to be kicked out of university, Perfume Girl called on people to “abolish compulsory foreign language education.” This article describes how “foreign languages holding the lives of Chinese people to ransom,” how languages are emphasised at every stage of a young person’s development: from aged three, where “tiny souls are bewildered by foreign languages;” through to graduation where “spoken English, business English and all sorts of foreign language certification, are enough to stress anyone out.”


Apart from a few nicely-written slogans and the amusing Zhao Benshan analogy, there is nothing special about these comments. Miss Wang’s blog entries are hardly objective criticisms, and like a lot of the Chinese articles I read, they lack logical reasoning and are not backed up with evidence. Her arguments could be summarised into two points: foreign language requirements might hold back those who would otherwise succeed in other subjects; and that many resent studying foreign languages in China.

Both might be acceptable evils if the current system was improving the level of English in China. However, if China's schools are making many unhappy and are stifling talent, then considering my experience of the English levels despite compulsory study, The Peking Order thinks that these complaints are legitimate and that it maybe about time for a drastic rethink of China's education system.

According to a recent entry on Perfume Girl's blog, hackers have deleted all offending entries. Luckily, others have posted full copies of what she wrote:

Zhao Benshan for Education Minister (Chinese)
Foreign languages depriving Chinese of right to education (Chinese)
Foreign languages holding Chinese people to ransom (Chinese)


Horlic said...

Huh!! Pretty Girl

Horlic said...

Huh!! Pretty Girl

Anonymous said...

fucking lol still stuck on the velour suits jez its got you writing essays here....

Anonymous said...

[url=]laws for online gambling[/url] [url=]online gambling no deposit bonus[/url] [url=]poker rooms gambling free online[/url] [url=]free online casino advertising[/url] [url=]online gambling for americans[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hi I'm Gary from and we've got quite the riveting collection of [url=]drum sets[/url]. The exact amassment of drum appurtenances components depends on factors like euphonious taste, in the flesh preference, financial resources, and transportation options of the drummer. Cymbal, hi-hat, and tom-tom stands (if it comes with), as well as bass drum pedals and drum thrones are generally speaking footing in most drum kits. Most mass produced drum kits are sold in one of two five-piece configurations (referring to the swarm of drums merely), which typically include a bass drum, a snare drum, two toms, and individual fell tom. The pattern sizes (sometimes called ‘in ruins’ sizes) are 22” (entirely size diameter) bass drum, 14” snare drum, 12” and 13” mounted toms, and a 16” floor tom. The other popular configuration is called "Fusion", a notation to jazz fusion music, which usually includes a 20” (or off 22") bass drum, a 14” catch drum, and 10”, 12” mounted toms, and a 14” base tom.

Anonymous said...

mmesOEG - hallo guys :D

Anonymous said...

[url=]Andrew Luck Nike Jersey[/url]

We avoid dealing with it all together or give it only the briefest attention4There is a powerful quote by Stephen Jay Gould who said, "The center of human nature is rooted in ten thousand ordinary acts of kindness that define our days Over $100,000 of real problems that should have been detected during the business purchase process popped up and almost shut Martin down

[url=]Nike J.J. Watt Jersey[/url]

When I come into that inheritance, I'll ___ It says a "quart of wheat for a denariousEmergency 5: Dog ChokingOpen the dog's mouth carefully and try to see what is causing the problem The Universe will look at you and say, "Alright, you've got it! Let's give you a little more

[url=]Frank Gore 49ers Jersey[/url]

Anonymous said...

Deine Meinung kann ich nicht nachvollziehen. Kannst du den 1.
Teil nochmal erklären?
my web page - E-Zigarette

Anonymous said...

top [url=]casino bonus[/url] check the latest [url=]online casino[/url] unshackled no deposit perk at the leading [url=]loose largesse casino

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye.